‘Agatha All Along’ Episode 4: Marvel fans cook up crazy theories after ‘Teen isn’t Agatha’s son’ revelation

It is no secret there’s a tremendous mystery surrounding the origin and identity of Joe Locke’s Teen. For now, all we know is that someone placed a magical sigil on him that prevents the young boy from sharing his real name to the witch community. However, looking at how he helped Agatha break free from Wanda’s spell and him joining the enchantress on the legendary Witches’ Road, it is clear Teen has a significant role to play in the Agatha All Along storyline.

Initially, online Marvel theorists placed their bets on Teen being Billy Kaplan, a sorcerer and the reincarnation of one of Wanda’s twin sons. But the Mephisto name-drop in episode three last weekend, shifted the speculation tide to Teen being Agatha’s son Nicholas, who she allegedly traded to procure the Book of the Damned.

Rio telling Agatha teen isn’t her son #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/kWLDWLt94i
— Mariel ✨ (@maslanyshulk) October 3, 2024

agatha’s face when rio said that teen isn’t her son WHEN WILL THE SUFFERING END #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/PrceeURLhZ
— em ⚢ || AGATHA ERA (@cowboylikehers) October 3, 2024

Well, now we are back to square one. In Agatha All Along episode 4, released October 3, witch Rio Viday (Played by Aubrey Plaza) tells Agatha, Teen isn’t her son. It didn’t take long for fans to jump back to their original hypothesis that Teen’s secrecy might just be the answer to Wanda aka Scarlet Witch’s return to the MCU, a character played by Elizabeth Olsen, who died during the events of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness

“Agatha.. that boy isn’t yours” #AgathaAllAlong #AgathaAllAlongBash

pic.twitter.com/OnqoVvJVnK
— ‎ً (@wicckaris) October 3, 2024

“Agatha, that boy isn’t yours” ALL I DO ON THIS APP IS CRY #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/WcJryl9eQe
— ໊ (@wandasattorney) October 3, 2024

A section of fans reacting to Teen and Agatha’s discussion on how a magical sigil works, claim Teen is Wanda’s son. A fan wrote “This is definitely Wanda casting the sigil to protect Teen’s identity, but to suppress her identity as well as The Scarlet Witch.”

“A sigil works on a witch who casts it as well. That’s why we don’t use them as much. They’re super irritating.”

This is definitely Wanda casting the sigil to protect Teen’s identity, but to suppress her identity as well as The Scarlet Witch. #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/9hLS84ZHuL
— Dick Grayson (@BruceWayne9851) October 3, 2024

agatha when she finds out teen is wanda’s son and rio wants to kill her again #AgathaAllAlong https://t.co/DdHVwfhBDo
— obi mer (@pipr6vi) October 3, 2024

#AgathaAllAlong rio def sold Nicholas scratch for the dark hold and knows where he is and knows teen isn’t him
— Chris 💚🌺 (@crispychris_777) October 3, 2024

Agatha started having a glimmer of hope that Teen is her son, to the extent that she was about to forgive Rio, but reality kicked in and she’s back to square one #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/VbuRFJmW2t
— marie (@etherealolsen_) October 3, 2024

I’m glad they revealed Teen isn’t agatha’s son tonight because we got bigger fish to fry in this bewitching mystery! Thank u next! #AgathaAllAlong #AgathaAllAlongBash
— Chris Del Rey (@ChrisMDelRey) October 3, 2024

Meanwhile, many remained confused if ‘Teen isn’t Agatha’s son’ revelation by Rio is really the confirmation that Teen isn’t Nicholas.

ok sooo let’s debrief. i assume that rio is death??? like a grim reaper type of figure??? and she had to take agatha’s son (to the afterlife??? or wherever??) and agatha blames/blamed her for it

so was that confirmation that teen is not nicholas??#AgathaAllAlong
— 𝖑𝖔𝖌 🪷 (@ijbologan) October 3, 2024

The Teen is Nicholas theory still stands because if there’s one thing Marvel is known for is lying straight to your face without blinking idc #AgathaAllAlong
— Kayla Harrington (@oh_kayx) October 3, 2024

#AgathaAllAlong   
So with out mcu context the show is presenting us:
Agatha and Rio were partners ( in the literal and lover sence ) and Rio had to do something that hurt agatha ( take her child)
Now agatha believe teen is her son and that’s why he had a signal.
*continued
— t-raex (@raeSilly00) October 3, 2024

Whew the drama so Agatha sold her baby to her husband (Mephisto/Devil) and her lesbian lover is (Death) and had to take her baby (3 of swords) to him which is why it’s beef with them and she thinks teen is hers whole time its Wanda #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/ZZhNyKJfeF
— Ty’Jhay (@TyJhayMB) October 3, 2024

What if it’s Rio who put the sigil on Teen’s mouth?? #AgathaAllAlong
— Aunt Damodred (@silverpike_95) October 3, 2024

Then there are those who’ve grown excited to learn how Agatha will react upon learning Teen is Wanda’s son.

Will Agatha crash out once she finds out teen is Wanda’s son (allegedly)? #AgathaAllAlong
— Khen Carzon (@khencarzon) October 3, 2024

Ohhh this woman will go nuts when she finds out who teen really is… #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/nSjfRJ0pML
— Jonathan 🗯️ | fan account (@Jonisedits) October 3, 2024

I just know Agatha is gonna pop a blood vessel when she finds out who Teen really is #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/0M95vPMvcY
— Hannah (they/them) (@halodude2014) October 3, 2024

#AgathaAllAlong
AGATHA DOING ALL THIS FOR TEEN SHES GONNA BE SOOOOO PISSED WHEN SHE FINDS OUT WHO’S KID HE REALLY IS 😭😭😭 pic.twitter.com/3JIwAhGeHJ
— ໊ (@wandasattorney) October 3, 2024

the idea of agatha and teen both believing that he’s agatha’s lost child only for it to turn out that he’s not will COMPLETELY fuck me up #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/qWYXaVFA3a
— rei 🌧️ loves joe locke (@heartstperxjoe) October 3, 2024

#AgathaAllAlong
–
–
–
–
–
Agatha was thinking that the teen was his son all along. pic.twitter.com/vRNDhOUsOz
— katze🇺🇾 (@tssswift_) October 3, 2024

“That boy isnt yours” don’t get nasty Rio 😭😭😭 I still think that’s Teen is Agatha kid and if not well that’s his mother now #AgathaAllAlong pic.twitter.com/Nw8bIs8f85
— 𝓅𝓇𝒾𝓃𝒸ℯ𝓈𝓈𝒶🌸 (@prinxprincessa) October 3, 2024

#AgathaAllAlong

[SPOILERS]

Teen starting to bleed out after the second trial really had me on the EDGE OF MY SEAT.

Look at how Agatha starts losing her mind (as if he was her son)—deep down she truly cares for him and this scene shows that clearly. pic.twitter.com/M5iOkza4MF
— Jordan Jones (@jordnjnes) October 3, 2024

the fallout we’re gonna see when agatha finds out what’s under teens sigil and rio goes back to trying to kill her is gonna be so bad… #AgathaAllAlong #AgathaAllAlongBash pic.twitter.com/szIRHoC3em
— anthony (@lizziesjuul) October 3, 2024

i can’t help but wonder if teen is pretending and he knows everything and he’s just playing w agatha oh my god that would be so,,,, #AgathaAllAlong https://t.co/m2fwFHR0BD
— َ (@timeylunar) October 3, 2024